Contact a manager: +998 99 723-04-44
GuideLaw

A rental deposit: how to get it back without a conflict

Updated 8 min

A man packing a box when moving out

The deposit is the most common cause of quarrels between owners and tenants. The tenant is sure they left the apartment in good order; the owner sees a stain on the sofa and a gas bill unpaid. In the end both feel cheated, and a calm conversation about money turns into a row. Almost all such conflicts can be prevented on move-in day, and the rest calmly resolved on move-out day. Let’s look at how to set up a deposit so that getting it back goes without conflict for both sides.

What a deposit is and what it protects against

A deposit is money the tenant gives the owner at the start of a let as a guarantee. If everything is in order at move-out, it’s returned in full. If there’s damage, unpaid utilities or unpaid rent, the owner may withhold from it exactly as much as is needed to cover them - provided the agreement says so.

It’s important not to confuse the deposit with the last month’s rent. Sometimes a tenant decides “I won’t pay for the last month, let them take it from the deposit”. That’s a bad idea: if damage is found after move-out, there’s nothing left to cover it, and a dispute becomes inevitable. It’s better for the deposit and the rent to live separately, and for the agreement to say so.

The parties set the size of the deposit themselves, and there’s no universal amount. It’s more sensible to start not from “what’s usual” but from what the deposit needs to cover:

  • How much furniture and how many appliances the apartment has, and what repairing or replacing them costs.
  • Whether there will be pets or small children in the apartment.
  • How long the let is and how often the owner can check the apartment.
  • How utilities are paid: bills in the owner’s name or the tenant’s.

Too large a deposit scares off good tenants; too small a one doesn’t protect the owner. Discuss the amount openly and write down which risks it insures against - then it won’t seem arbitrary.

What to write about the deposit in the agreement

The deposit terms are a short but important block of the rental agreement. Every wording here answers a question that would otherwise come up on move-out day.

Deposit clauses in the agreement

Scroll the table sideways

ClauseHow to write itWhich dispute it prevents
Amount and currencyHow to write itThe deposit amount and how it was handed overWhich dispute it prevents“I gave more” - “no, less”
What it can be withheld forHow to write itDamage beyond wear, unpaid utilities and rentWhich dispute it preventsWithholding “for everything” with no explanation
What it isn’t withheld forHow to write itNormal wear and tear from living thereWhich dispute it preventsAn argument about worn lino after two years
Return deadlineHow to write itWithin how many days of move-outWhich dispute it prevents“I’ll return it when I find new tenants”
How the amount is settledHow to write itA written breakdown of any amount withheldWhich dispute it preventsWithholding with no figures or justification

The parties set the amounts and deadlines themselves. The table shows what needs to be written down so there are no questions on move-out day.

The other key clauses of a rental agreement - payment, house rules, early move-out - are covered in our article on the rental agreement.

Cleaning the apartment before moving out

Move-in day is the foundation of the return

The fate of the deposit is decided not on move-out day but on move-in day. Anything not recorded when the tenant moves in later becomes one word against another. So the handover report deserves more attention than any other rental document.

  • An inventory of furniture and appliances with their condition: “a scratch on the wardrobe door”, not “used wardrobe”.
  • Photos and video of every room - wide shots and close-ups of every defect, files with both sides.
  • All meter readings, in figures and in photos.
  • The number of keys, remotes and access cards handed over.
  • Both parties’ signatures on the report - it becomes an annex to the agreement.

If the tenant finds a defect a few days after moving in, they should report it in writing with a photo straight away. That way it won’t end up on the list of claims at move-out, and the owner has time to decide whether to fix it now.

Wear or damage: where the line is

The most common subject of dispute is what counts as damage. An apartment lived in for a year can’t look new, and that’s normal. Withholding the deposit for natural wear is unfair, but the tenant is responsible for what they broke or spoiled.

Normal wear

The deposit isn’t withheld

  • Scuffs on the floor where people walk
  • Small marks from furniture on the walls
  • Curtains faded by the sun
  • Hinges and handles loosened by frequent use

Who pays the owner, it’s part of letting

Damage

Grounds for withholding

  • A burnt worktop or stains on furniture
  • Broken glass or a broken appliance
  • Holes in walls beyond the agreed shelves
  • Signs of pets, if pets weren’t allowed

Who pays the tenant, from the deposit

The line isn’t always obvious, so it’s better to discuss it with concrete examples when signing the agreement. In disputed cases a simple question helps: would this have happened in any apartment from ordinary life, or is it the result of carelessness?

The move-out routine

Moving out goes calmly and without unpleasant surprises when both sides know the routine in advance. It’s convenient to set it out step by step and agree on it a few weeks before the date.

Moving out and returning the deposit

A routine that removes most disputes

  1. Give noticeIn advance, per the agreement

    In writing, within the period set in the agreement - with the move-out date.

  2. Settle the billsA week before

    Pay utilities and internet up to the final readings and keep the receipts.

  3. Clean and clear outThe day before

    Remove belongings, clean, put furniture back as listed in the inventory.

  4. Joint inspectionMove-out day

    The owner and tenant walk through with the move-in report and photos in hand.

  5. Check and settleOn the spot

    Meter readings, keys, a list of comments and the amount withheld, if any.

  6. Return the depositWithin the agreed period

    The deposit or the balance with a written breakdown - by transfer or against a receipt.

The deadlines are those set in the agreement. The key is a joint inspection with the move-in report, not an assessment from memory.

If a dispute does arise

Even with a good agreement, the parties sometimes disagree on an assessment. At that moment the most important thing is to keep a calm tone and rely on documents, not emotions.

  • Compare the apartment’s condition with the move-in report and photos, not with memories.
  • Withhold only what you can justify: the cost of a repair or replacement, not “just in case”.
  • Offer a partial deduction with a breakdown instead of keeping the whole deposit.
  • Record agreements in writing - by message or receipt.
  • If you can’t agree, consult a lawyer: the rules for resolving such disputes are worth checking.

Remember that a dispute over a deposit almost always costs little compared with the time and nerves lost. It pays the owner to settle with a reasonable compromise and earn a good review, and the tenant to leave with a recommendation that will help with the next let.

Correspondence about the deposit is a document too. If it’s kept in the agency’s shared channel rather than on personal phones, a month later it’s easy to find who promised what. In an agency, Chats are handy for this: Telegram conversations with the tenant and the owner go through the agency bot and are kept on the client card.

How a realtor helps

If a realtor or agency handles the let, returning the deposit goes noticeably more smoothly. The realtor takes part in the inspection as a neutral party, keeps the report, photos and agreement, and knows what was agreed. They’re also interested in the apartment quickly finding its next tenant: a property that becomes free can be sent right away as a selection to clients looking to rent in that district.

An owner letting an apartment for the first time will find our guide to letting an apartment useful, and a tenant our tenant’s guide.

This article describes general residential rental practice and isn’t legal advice. The parties set the deposit amount, return deadlines and grounds for withholding in the agreement.

Read next