Contact a manager: +998 99 723-04-44
For realtorsAnalytics

When the seller overprices: how a realtor talks about price in market terms

Updated 7 min

A realtor and owners discussing the price

Almost every realtor has heard it: “My apartment is worth more - the neighbours are asking more.” Arguing with a seller about price is pointless - they are defending not a number but their investment, expectations and plans. What works is showing the market the way a buyer sees it and agreeing not on “the right price” but on a plan that the market itself will test within a few weeks. Let’s look at how to prepare for the conversation, how to run it and when it’s better to walk away from the property.

Why sellers overprice

An inflated price is almost never pure greed. It has understandable causes, and the conversation depends on which one is the main one.

  • Purchase price plus renovation: “I put in this much, I can’t sell for less.”
  • A neighbour’s listing: the seller sees someone else’s asking price and takes it for a sale price.
  • Room to bargain: “I’ll set it higher, they’ll haggle anyway.”
  • The amount needed: for the next apartment, a move, debts - the price is calculated from the need.
  • Another realtor’s promise: someone named a higher figure to win the listing.
  • Emotion: the apartment where the children grew up feels more valuable than any next door.

It’s worth spending the first ten minutes of the meeting understanding which reason is yours. The answer to “I put money into the renovation” and the answer to “I need exactly this much for the new apartment” are different conversations.

The hardest case is when the price is calculated from need: the seller needs a specific sum for the next purchase. Arguing about the market is pointless here, but you can discuss options: a different apartment to buy, a different district, a top-up payment, an instalment plan, timing. Sometimes an honest calculation - “what this apartment really sells for and what that money can buy” - helps the seller more than months of waiting for a buyer at an impossible price. And it’s a conversation after which they trust you with both deals: the sale and the purchase.

Preparation: facts before the conversation

A realtor who comes to the meeting with a feeling that it’s “a bit pricey” loses to a seller with the feeling that it’s “fine”. You need to arrive with facts the seller can check themselves.

What to gather before a price conversation

Scroll the table sideways

What to gatherWhere to get itWhat it shows
Comparable active listingsWhere to get itSame district, building type, areaWhat it showsWho the apartment will compete with tomorrow
Withdrawn listings of comparablesWhere to get itProperty history in the market mirrorWhat it showsAt what price apartments left the market
Comparables’ days on marketWhere to get itDates of first listing and removalWhat it showsHow long expensive ones sit versus those within the range
Competitors’ price historyWhere to get itPrice cuts by propertyWhat it showsWho already tried starting high and how it ended
A benchmark from comparablesWhere to get itA valuation of the property from comparable apartmentsWhat it showsThe range and the apartment’s place in it, with its make-up

A listing being removed is an indirect sign of a sale, not a confirmed deal. Tell the seller so directly: an honest method is an argument too.

Gathering such a set by hand takes an hour per property. Realtors who work with a valuation by comparable properties bring it to the meeting as a printout or open it on their phone: the benchmark, the typical price range of similar homes and the similar listings themselves.

A conversation at a table over coffee

The conversation, step by step

The goal of the meeting isn’t to convince the seller of your number but to agree on how the market will test the price. Then the seller doesn’t lose an argument - they make a decision based on facts.

A price conversation with a seller

The order of a 30-40 minute meeting

  1. Hear where the number comes from5 minutes

    The purchase price, renovation, a neighbour, the sum needed for the next apartment - each reason has its own answer.

  2. Show the market through a buyer’s eyes10 minutes

    A feed of similar apartments with prices per metre: how a buyer sees them on their phone in the evening.

  3. Separate asking and sale prices5 minutes

    The price in a neighbour’s listing is what they ask, not what they sold for.

  4. Offer a range, not one number5 minutes

    Lower and upper bounds from comparables and where the apartment sits within the range, with an explanation.

  5. Agree on a plan with dates5 minutes

    The starting price, checkpoints, what we change if there are no calls or viewings.

  6. Put the agreement in writingAfter the meeting

    A short message to the seller with the price, dates and review criteria.

The timing is a guide. The most important step is the fifth: without a plan with dates, the price conversation will repeat in a month.

A word on step three. Sellers almost always compare their apartment with listings - that is, with asking prices. Show them how long the most expensive of those listings stay up and how often they get cut. It explains the difference between the price people ask and the price people pay better than any words. In the market mirror this history is visible for every property: the date of the first listing, every price change, the removal.

Objections and fact-based answers

What the seller says and how to answer

Scroll the table sideways

The seller saysA fact-based answer
“The neighbours are asking more”A fact-based answerThat’s an asking price. Let’s look together at how long it has been up and whether it was cut.
“I invested in the renovation”A fact-based answerBuyers pay for condition, not receipts. The renovation is accounted for: we compare with apartments in similar condition.
“Let’s set it higher and bargain later”A fact-based answerAt an inflated price buyers don’t bargain - they just don’t call. The bargaining margin eats the calls at the start.
“Another realtor promised more”A fact-based answerAsk them to show their comparables. If there’s a justification - great; if not, it’s a promise to win the contract.
“I’m in no hurry”A fact-based answerThen it’s all the more worth agreeing a review date, so the apartment doesn’t sit for six months and become “old”.

A seller argues with your opinion. It’s harder to argue with the market they can see on the screen.

A plan with dates instead of an argument

Sometimes a seller isn’t ready to accept the range straight away, and that’s normal. A workable compromise is to start at their price but agree checkpoints in advance, in writing: if within the agreed period there are no viewings, or there are viewings but no offers, the price changes by the agreed step. It makes sense to tie the period to the typical days on market of comparable apartments, not to mood.

The usual way

An argument about price

  • The realtor says “expensive”, the seller says “fine”
  • The apartment goes up at the seller’s price with no conditions
  • A month later the same conversation, but the listing is already “old”
  • Cuts in small steps, each one a fight

How it can be

An agreement to let the market decide

  • The seller sees the range and comparables themselves
  • The starting price and review dates are written down
  • A report every week: calls, viewings, feedback
  • The price decision rests on numbers, not an argument

The weekly report is what keeps the plan alive. How many calls, how many viewings, what buyers said, which competitors appeared or got cheaper. A seller reads such a report more carefully than any argument at the meeting, because it’s their apartment and their market.

When to walk away from a listing

Not every listing is worth taking. If the seller rejects any plan, demands an exclusive at a price well above the range and won’t consider a review under any circumstances, you’ll spend months advertising an apartment that doesn’t sell and explaining it to your buyers. An honest refusal with an explanation and an offer to talk again in a month often works better than agreeing: the seller remembers the realtor who didn’t promise the impossible.

The live figures are aggregates from the Titul mirror for apartment sale listings: we see asking prices, not transaction prices, and treat a listing being removed as an indirect sign of a sale.

Read next