What a minute of silence costs: response time and conversion

An enquiry does not spoil because the client changed their mind. It spoils with time: while you are out at a viewing, the person messages three more agencies - and talks to whoever answered first. The cost of silence has been measured openly more than once; here is what those measurements showed and how to turn them into an agency's arithmetic.
What the published research showed
The most-cited measurement of response speed is the work of James Oldroyd and co-authors: first the Lead Response Management Study (2007), then “The Short Life of Online Sales Leads” in Harvard Business Review (March 2011). The latter examined 2,241 US companies and how long they took to answer an inbound web enquiry. Three numbers speak for themselves.
The table scrolls sideways
| What was measured | Result | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Replying in 5 minutes vs 30 minutes | Result21× higher odds of qualifying the lead | SourceLead Response Management Study, 2007 |
| Replying within an hour vs 1–2 hours | Result7× higher odds of qualifying the lead | SourceHBR, 2011 |
| Replying within an hour vs after 24 hours | Result60× higher odds of qualifying the lead | SourceHBR, 2011 |
| Average time to first response (among those replying within 30 days) | Result42 hours | SourceHBR, 2011 |
| Companies that never replied at all | Result23% of companies never replied | SourceHBR, 2011 |
Sources: Oldroyd, Elkington. Lead Response Management Study, 2007; Oldroyd, McElheran, Elkington. The Short Life of Online Sales Leads. Harvard Business Review, March 2011 (sample: 2,241 US companies, inbound web enquiries). Read it in Harvard Business Review
How time to first response was distributed
Share of companies in the HBR 2011 sample, totalling 100%
Why the first hour decides it
The reason is not politeness, nor a “hot lead”. An enquiry lives exactly as long as the person keeps the task in their head. An hour later they are talking to another agency; a day later they have already seen two properties. You are not losing on service - you are simply joining a conversation that has already ended.
Response speed is the only competitive advantage that costs neither budget nor new listings. It is enough to stop losing the enquiry in someone's pocket.
The arithmetic for an agency with 100 enquiries
Turn that into money on a worked example. Take an agency with 100 enquiries a month and assume 6 of them reach a deal. In the HBR study almost a quarter of companies never replied to the test enquiry at all. If your agency treats even a quarter of its enquiries that way, that is not “bad conversion” - that is a quarter of paid traffic thrown away before the first conversation.
While you stay silent
The enquiry waits for a free agent
- The enquiry is visible to one person - whoever received it
- Nobody knows how long it has been waiting
- Night and weekend enquiries are read on Monday
- “I thought you would answer” is the usual post-mortem
By the time you call, the client is already talking to others
When there is a deadline
The enquiry has an owner and a clock
- It lands in a shared queue and is assigned immediately
- An overdue reply is visible to the manager the same day
- Overnight enquiries sit at the top of the morning list
- The reply is recorded - there is nothing to argue about
By the time you call, the client is still choosing
How to answer fast without living on the phone
Answering within five minutes around the clock is neither necessary nor possible. Something else is: the enquiry must not sit in someone's pocket, and it must have a deadline. The routine below works in a team of three and in a team of thirty.
- Bring every channel into one place: calls, Telegram, website and listing-board enquiries. While there are five channels, “fast” is organisationally impossible.
- Agree a deadline and write it down: one hour during business hours, by 10 a.m. for overnight enquiries. An unwritten deadline is a wish.
- Assign an owner the moment the enquiry arrives, not at the morning meeting. An enquiry with no owner has no measurable response time.
- Keep a short first-reply template: confirm receipt and ask one clarifying question. It takes a minute and holds the client until you are free.
- Count the median response time weekly and review it with the team. That alone usually moves the number more than any demand does.
The research figures are quoted with their sources and describe US B2B companies. The 100-enquiry example is an arithmetic illustration, not a measurement across Titul customers: the platform publishes no response-speed measurements of its own.


